NEWS DETAIL

Don't Waste your Stubs! | The Cards you should really get for Each Position in MLB The Show 26 Don't Waste your Stubs! | The Cards you should really get for Each Position in MLB The Show 26

Don't Waste your Stubs! | The Cards you should really get for Each Position in MLB The Show 26

Apr 08, 2026 Source: UTNICE More News

In MLB The Show 26, have you completed your collection and acquired the cards, but unsure how to arrange your lineup? This guide will teach you how to build the best lineup for each position.

Catchers

Fifth on the list is Salvador Perez. His swing is smooth, and he's inexpensive, costing only 15,000 stubs. If you don't have that many, you can buy MLB 26 stubs directly from Utnice.com; this card is definitely worth buying. 

Fourth is Live Series Cal Raleigh, suitable for All-Star difficulty. His price is high, so it's not recommended to waste your money. New players can try him out.

Third is Will Smith. Arguably the best budget catcher, with a good swing, and his defense can be improved through Parallel Mods.

Second is Roy Campanella. Excellent on both offense and defense, fast, and possesses the two most important quirks: Dead Red and Breaking Ball Hitter. Some find the swing difficult to adapt to, while others find it perfectly fine.Don't Waste your Stubs! | The Cards you should really get for Each Position in MLB The Show 26

The top catcher is Adley Rutschman. His form is much better this year than last, his defense is good, and his speed is considered fast for a catcher. He has a Dead Red and a First Pitch, but lacks a Breaking Ball Hitter. Overall, however, he remains the strongest catcher currently.

In addition, there are two honorary nominees, Joe Mauer and Harry Ford. While Harry Ford's speed isn't what it used to be, he's still worth a try.

First Base

There are several ties for first base: Vinnie Pasquantino, Bryce Harper, and David Ortiz.

Vinnie Pasquantino's defense is practically nonexistent, his hitting is decent, his clutch isn't high, but he's not too bad against lefties. Bryce Harper is a bit weaker but faster, and his defense is slightly better than Vinnie Pasquantino's. David Ortiz has the best quirks of the three; his swing is a matter of personal preference.

Next on the list is Munetaka Murakami. His power is significantly higher than the three above, his swing is extremely smooth, his speed is average, and his defense is decent.

The second-place finisher at first base is Carlos Santana. He has a First Pitch and Dead Red, better quirks, and is the best defensive first baseman in the game.

Undoubtedly, the first place is Albert Pujols. He has almost all the important quirks, good power, defense, and speed; he can even play third base.

Second Base

Fifth place is JJ Wetherholt. He's fast, has a decent swing, and is generally very solid.

Fourth place has two ties: Mookie Betts and Didi Gregorius. Mookie Betts has poor defense but is quite fast. Didi Gregorius is similar to Mookie, with poor defense but a powerful hit, even faster speed, good quirks, and many people love his swing.

Third place is Chone Figgins. His swing isn't very attractive, but his speed and defense are good.

The second-place finisher at second base is Ozzie Albies. Excellent swing, average quirks, decent speed.

The most recommended second baseman is Ketel Marte. A very strong offensive second baseman, average defense, quick reflexes, and irreplaceable hitting value as a second baseman.

Third Base

Greg Nettles, ranked fifth at third base, has good defense and a decent swing.

Fourth is Kazuma Okamoto, good swing, also has a dead red, and relatively strong power.

Next is Maikel Garcia, the most overpriced card, possibly the best defense, but low cost-effectiveness.

Second on third base is Willi Castro, his actual performance exceeds his stats, and he is generally recommended.

The best third baseman is José Ramírez, the consensus number one. Although his defense is inconsistent, his high vision makes him a viable option for second base.

Shortstop

Fifth is Geraldo Perdomo. Low power but possesses Dead Red and Breaking Ball Hitter abilities, decent speed, and good defense; one of the most underrated cards.

Fourth shortstop: Leo De Vries has three of the most important quirks and is budget-friendly.

Third: Corey Seager has an excellent swing, average arm strength, but good overall defense.

Second: Francisco Lindor. Although his defense is relatively weak, he has good quirks, and his swing is consistently popular with players.

First shortstop: Troy Tulowitzki is arguably the best. All his stats are outrageous, and he has a complete set of important quirks.

Left Field

Actually, the left field position is currently relatively scarce, so only three players are recommended here.

Third on the list is Roman Anthony. Around 15,000 stubs; slightly lacking in power, but otherwise passable.

Second: Andrew McCutchen; his swing is consistently good, his defense is poor but he's well-suited for the left field position.

A highly recommended player is Lance Berkman. Extremely effective against righties, but somewhat weak against lefties. Overall, he's still very reliable.

Center Field

Fifth place: Jackson Chourio's swing is better than expected, but he lacks power.

Next is Max Clark; good contact, lacks power, and his defense is average.

Third place: Julio Rodríguez is also an overvalued player; his hitting is average and he needs improvement in many areas.

Then Byron Buxton is highly recommended. 99 speed, good power, already excellent.

First place is undoubtedly Mike Trout. Top-tier hitting, and his defense is sufficient; a blind pick.

Right Field

Jeremy Bennett is worth recommending; he's strong against righties, and his swing is reportedly very good.

Ronald Acuña Jr. has good hitting and strong arms, but his defensive reaction is somewhat poor.

Third place is Ken Singleton; his stats are decent, but his 59 speed severely hinders his defense.

Second place goes to Aaron Judge. His hitting is near-collectible level, and his defense makes up for it, making him worth using.

The top spot for right field belongs to Fernando Tatis Jr. He's an all-around player with a good swing, good defense, and high speed.

So, these are the recommended players for each position. If you're lucky enough to own any of the players on this list, start using them in MLB 26!

Recommended Article
0
Shopping Cart

Your Shopping Cart Is Empty

Total 1 item
Total: 8.44

Are you sure to delete the selected items ?

Connecting to online customer service, please wait.

.